Trance
Trance, an expanded remake of a TV movie written and directed
by Joe Ahearne in 2001, opens with a Scorsese-style illustrated lecture —
narrated by protagonist Simon, played by James McAvoy with a Scots
smartarsiness that can’t help but evoke once-upon-a-time Boyle fixture Ewan
McGregor in his amoral boyish-grin phase
Like
Inception, Fight Club, Total Recall or The Sixth Sense, Trance is an awkward
film to discuss without giving too much away, but actually quite difficult to
spoil
Simon,
Elizabeth and Franck are difficult to care about, even before the script gets
to going over its story several more times filling in narrative gaps with
information which compromises any possible empathy we might feel for them. And
it doesn’t stop with the end of the film — you can argue on the way home who
the most reprehensible person is, or even whose trance we’ve been in, and
whether the final explanation given is even final.
127 Hours
This
vibrancy is there right from the start. We’ve known that Danny Boyle can work
wonders with dark subject-matters: in Slumdog Millionaire families endure
unimaginable poverty, women are forced into prostitution and child beggars have
their eyes gouged out by evil Fagins — even if it was described by the News Of
The World as “the feel-good film of the decade”. But 127 Hours takes it to a
whole new level, kicking off with a split-screen credit sequence that plays
like a hyperactive Coke Zero ad, transposing solo images of James
Franco-as-Ralston against vivid crowd scenes, not so much showing him as a
loner but as a micro-unit in the teeming metropolis of life.
What
Ralston does to get free is a thing of gruesome, nauseating wonder, but Boyle
doesn’t linger on the horror. Instead, he portrays it for what it is: a painful
liberation. And this is the film’s most magnificent achievement; though it
appears to be about all sorts of grim nonsense, the actual message is not
simply one of hope, but one delivered with a zen-like calm, a soothing voice
that whispers, “This too shall pass,” in Boyle’s lovely Lancashire burr.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.